Originally published on CastAlbums.org.

Broadway Records took a double gamble by releasing the soundtrack to NBC’s Peter Pan Live. By releasing a true soundtrack (rather than a pre-recorded cast album, as the previous year’s Sound of Music Live did), they passed up any chance to sell the album to those of us curious to get a peek at the broadcast before airdate, and they staked their success on a positive reception of the broadcast itself.

While the television production had its moments, it largely seemed dead on arrival: neither the thrilling spectacle NBC dreamed of, nor the campy disaster hate-watchers hoped for. As the broadcast limped along, I couldn’t imagine wanting to revisit this experience on a soundtrack album. I’m glad to report that I was wrong. Continue reading →